Sign inCreate free account

Comparison

OpenV, StrictDoc and Doorstop: requirements as files in Git, or in a shared app

StrictDoc and Doorstop are free, open-source tools that keep requirements as text files in your Git repository, installed with pip and run from the command line or a local web page. OpenV is open source too, but it is an application with a database: a team works in one live project in the browser, hosted at openv.app or on your own server. Choose files in Git when requirements should live and be reviewed beside the code; choose OpenV when people who never open the repository need to read, review and verify them.

Checked by Desktop Machine Shop, the makers of OpenV, against each vendor’s own pages. Something out of date? Tell us.

Which to choose

Choose StrictDoc and Doorstop if
  • You want requirements in plain text files in the same Git repository as the code, reviewed in pull requests.
  • You want a command-line tool you install with pip and run in CI, with no server to keep.
  • You want StrictDoc’s document templates from DO-178C or ECSS-E-ST-40C to start from.
  • You want Doorstop’s YAML files, one per requirement, edited in any text editor.
Choose OpenV if
  • People who do not use Git need to read, review and approve requirements, on a computer or a phone.
  • You want test runs with recorded results and evidence with SHA-256 digests in the same project.
  • You want a plan, a board and baselines alongside the requirements.
  • You want AI agents that propose changes for review, on an AI subscription you already have.

Side by side

Each statement about StrictDoc and Doorstop is what their open-source projects says on its own pages, linked beside it.

 OpenV (hosted)StrictDoc and Doorstop
Licence and priceMIT License, free to self-host. Single User plan free; team plans are coming soon, and workspaces created during the alpha keep every feature free.StrictDoc is free under the Apache License 2.0. their open-source projects
Licence (Doorstop)MIT License.Doorstop is free under the LGPLv3. their open-source projects
Where requirements liveIn a Postgres database behind the app, hosted at openv.app or on your own server; export to JSON, ReqIF and documents at any time.StrictDoc keeps them in SDoc and Markdown text files; its local web page writes edits back to the files, and you commit them with Git. their open-source projects
Where requirements live (Doorstop)As above.Doorstop keeps each item as a YAML file in a directory under version control. their open-source projects
Links and suspect linksTyped, rule-checked links from needs to requirements, design, hazards and tests; suspect links; a traceability matrix and gap reports; immutable baselines with comparison.Doorstop stores the parent’s fingerprint with each link and reports the link suspect when the parent changes; doorstop clear confirms it. their open-source projects
Relations (StrictDoc)Link types with rules the server enforces: derives from, refines, satisfies, verifies, validates, mitigates and others.StrictDoc relations are Parent, Child and File, each with an optional role. their open-source projects
VerificationBuilt in: test runs recorded against test-case versions, evidence with SHA-256 digests, and a V&V status report.StrictDoc reads JUnit XML and Robot Framework XML test reports and reports documentation coverage. their open-source projects
ReqIFReqIF 1.x import and export. Round trips are tested OpenV to OpenV; exchange with other tools has not been tested yet.StrictDoc imports and exports ReqIF; its feature map marks this Experimental and tool-specific. their open-source projects
Other formatsExport to PDF, Word, Excel, CSV, JSON and ReqIF on every plan. Import reads JSON and ReqIF only.Doorstop imports and exports YAML, CSV, TSV and Excel files. their open-source projects
ReviewsReview rounds and a review queue; public read-only links, and reviewer links that let an outside reviewer sign in and comment without editing. No electronic signatures and no separate approver role.doorstop review marks an item, a document or everything as reviewed. their open-source projects
Getting startedA free account with no card, today. Or run it on your own machine with Docker Compose.pip install strictdoc, on Python 3.10 or later, on macOS, Linux or Windows. their open-source projects

Moving to OpenV

From StrictDoc, export ReqIF and import it into an OpenV project, then check counts by type, a sample of bodies and the links. StrictDoc marks its ReqIF Experimental and OpenV has not been tested against it, so move one document first.

From Doorstop, which does not list ReqIF among its formats, a short script can read the YAML files and create the artifacts and links through OpenV’s API or its MCP tools.

The ReqIF page says what an import and an export carry.

What OpenV does not do

  • No requirements stored as files in your own Git repository: they live in OpenV’s database, and Git sees only exports.
  • More to run than a command-line tool: self-hosting OpenV means a server with Postgres, kept up to date.
  • No Word, Excel or CSV import: requirements come in by ReqIF or OpenV’s own JSON.
  • OpenV is in alpha: features and screens still change between releases.